Transcript of an Interview with Analyst Michal Skořepa
The live presentation of the Czech Banking Association’s Macroeconomic Forecast is now behind us. However, what we presented lies ahead of us, and it might be good to say a few words about it. We have one of the panelists here with us, Michal Skořepa, an economic analyst at Česká spořitelna. Good afternoon.
Good morning.
How difficult is it to make a macroeconomic forecast these days? And I’ll go straight to the data. You’ve been revising the latest data—that is, the summer figures—and yet you remain consistently very optimistic about the future. So how difficult is it, actually, to get it right?
Well, it’s difficult, and in the last few quarters, it’s probably been even a bit harder. It’s hard to compare, because every era has its own risks, its own ambiguities, and its own uncertainties, but this one really stands out—at least partly because of who’s in the White House. That is, I’d say, a truly unprecedented source of all sorts of uncertainties, so it’s, I’d say, a factor that adds to the complexity. So yes, right now I’d say it’s a bit harder. It may cause the forecasts to fluctuate more over time. In fact, I think it’s even true that, for example, the Czech Statistical Office, when it repeatedly attempts to estimate the actual level of GDP for the Czech economy through these so-called revisions for the same period, it keeps receiving new information, so it keeps going back, say, to the first quarter of this year, and adjusts that figure at regular intervals—so the changes in those individual estimates are larger than they used to be. Simply because, overall, there is greater uncertainty in the economy, and in fact, there is also uncertainty regarding the past, since we don’t know it perfectly—and we rarely do.
So this is quite a problem now—I’d say a bigger one than in the past. So the old saying no longer holds true: When the German economy catches a cold, we sneeze. What holds true now is simply that we’ll have to see what America does.
Well, you’ve touched on a very interesting topic, I’d say—the relationship between the Czech and German economies. There were times when, to put it another way, another saying went that the Czech economy is essentially the seventeenth federal state from an economic standpoint—that we’re so tightly tied to the German economy—and that the “cold and sneeze” analogy actually held true. But that’s no longer entirely the case. In fact, it hasn’t been true for several years now. It’s a very liberating—I’d say—perspective to look at those statistics, which show that while Germany was stagnating until recently, thank God things are now starting to improve a bit, and some modest growth is beginning to emerge there. The question is, for how long? Since it’s largely driven by fiscal expansion there, it’s unclear how long the German government will be able to keep pumping new money into the economy—financially or mentally. Germans are very conservative, but the bottom line is that their stagnation over the past few years hasn’t particularly affected the Czech economy. The Czech figures are significantly better. Of course, we’re feeling the impact of high energy prices, tariffs, and other factors, as well as the war in Ukraine, but even in light of all these shocks, the fact remains that the Czech economy is growing quite respectably. So from this perspective, thank God, that quip you mentioned simply doesn’t hold true anymore. As for whether the Czech economy is currently just as closely tied to the U.S. as it is to Germany—I don’t think so. Germany is still a more important trading partner for us, but I’d say we’re no longer as terribly dependent on it as we used to be, which I think is great news. On the other hand, of course, any dependence is bad when times are tough, but it’s good when times are good. So if the Germans one day really take off and start growing very rapidly, we might not benefit as much from it, because we’ve simply decided in the meantime to shift our focus a bit elsewhere, and their economic engine won’t pull us along as much. But I’m a little worried that’s a long way off.
Let’s move on to the macroeconomic forecast. You, as the economic panel, continue to insist on that positive outlook. Actually, I mentioned that at the beginning. You said: “Okay, we had to make some revisions to the last macroeconomic forecast—and not minor ones—but we’re still very optimistic about 2027 and 2028.” Where does that optimism come from?
Well, first of all, I don’t think that optimism is all that dramatic. We need to keep in mind that the Czech economy is, so to speak, a slightly different beast than, say, the German economy in terms of long-term growth. We’re still converging; we’re still somewhat fresher, younger, livelier, and newer than Western economies like Germany, France, or the Netherlands. So it’s common to see higher growth rates here, and that should continue to be the case in the future. So I think the “Czech norm” simply lies somewhere slightly above 2 percent—2.2, 2.3, or 2.4 percent. These are roughly the rates we’d expect from the Czech economy if nothing bad or extremely good were happening in the world—if everything were simply running smoothly, as usual. So our forecast is slightly higher by a few tenths of a percentage point, but actually not by that much. And it’s higher simply because we do have some catching up to do. If we look, for example, at a comparison with 2019, we fell into that COVID-19 slump quite deeply and climbed out of it relatively slowly and over a long period. So, at this very moment, we’re roughly where the entire eurozone is in terms of how quickly it recovered during that period, but we should be higher precisely because we’re, as I said, a new, fresh, young economy. So even from this perspective alone, it’s clear that the last few years— let’s say starting with the pandemic, have hurt us a little more than we expected, and as a result, there’s sort of some hidden, deferred potential here that we haven’t realized in recent years, but which should now finally come to the fore. So from this perspective, it makes sense to expect growth rates above the normal 2.2, 2.3, or 2.4 percent for some time. But then it should return to those levels in the years to come.
Is that also why you expect the Czech National Bank to act the way you do? Because you’re actually counting on it to keep the base interest rate at the level it set at its last meeting.
That’s right. Many of us feel—and we hear this even in the political arena—that 4 percent is too high. Let’s look at the ECB—there, it’s much lower. But in a way, what I’m about to say will seem immoral or shocking to many of us, yet in a way, high interest rates in the Czech economy are a sign of its strength. That youthful energy again. We can think of it like this: it’s as if we have a pet at home and we need a sturdier collar for it, because it simply has more energy and needs to be held more firmly—it’s poised to pick up the pace. And that’s exactly the case with the Czech economy, which simply wants to grow richer. It wants to—or still has the potential—to catch up with the Germans, the French, the Dutch, and so on. And that can actually be achieved through only two channels, to put it simply: either through inflation or through the exchange rate. Since we’ve ruled out inflation—because Czech inflation should be on par with the eurozone in the long term, with a target of 2 percent for both—that leaves only the exchange rate. And the Czech National Bank is actually trying, through these higher interest rates, to ensure that inflation does indeed fall to 2 percent; and all that momentum—that convergence force we possess (which the Germans no longer have to the same extent)— we’re closing the gap thanks to that—will actually be channeled into the exchange rate, which should strengthen. Our forecast doesn’t call for any major strengthening right now, but we should see at least a slight movement in that direction going forward. So, essentially, these high interest rates are very closely tied to that spontaneous momentum that the Czech economy still possesses. And that’s actually a good thing. Of course, it has implications for those of us who want to take out mortgages and the like. It makes loans more expensive, but again, that’s because there are so many people interested in those loans—since we all have some projects in mind, or at least a relatively large number of us do, that we want to invest in. And that high interest rate is a way to select the most profitable projects from among them. So, of course, there’s a player here—Czech fiscal policy—that’s also putting pressure on the credit market with its bonds. My concern is that this is too much—that the Czech fiscal deficits are too high, that the government’s demand is too strong, and that, in a way, it’s harming the economy because it doesn’t leave enough room for private investment projects that would be better. But that’s just how it is. The government promises that things will start to improve starting in 2028. Let’s hope that’s the case. But in a nutshell, higher Czech interest rates aren’t necessarily a sign of any problem—that the Czech economy is ailing. On the contrary, it’s simply healthier and needs to be reined in a bit more sharply—more so than the economies of the eurozone.
Says Michal Skořepa of Česká spořitelna. Mr. Skořepa, thank you very much. And I hope that since we’ve ended on such an optimistic note, Jan Bureš won’t contradict me in the next part of the interview and that the next macroeconomic forecast won’t need to be revised. Thank you very much.
Thank you very much for having me.